Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Biscuit5100 Review's avatar

I came across this through LinkedIn and wanted to look a little deeper. I grew up in a very Christian community, and while I’m not a practicing Christian now, I still believe a strong Puritan foundation and upbringing can be immensely helpful and beneficial. I want to be clear that I have a great deal of respect for the Christian faith. That said, I also think this assessment is fundamentally flawed. The idea that America is or was ever intended to be a uniquely “Christian nation” is historically inaccurate, and framing it that way is deeply troubling. In fact, that belief itself often fuels the very social and political tensions we’re struggling with today.

I respect the role of the Bible and religion as a shared cultural language in early America, but that’s not the same as being our legal foundation. Most of the key founders were more accurately theists or deists, not orthodox Christians. And one of the earliest diplomatic documents, the Treaty of Tripoli (1797), stated clearly that “the government of the United States is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion.”

We can and should respect the role Christianity played in American history. The Bible served as a shared cultural language, and Christian communities played a significant role in shaping early civic life. But that doesn’t mean America was founded as a Christian nation. Moving forward, the healthiest path is to honor those historical values while also maintaining a fundamental separation between politics and religion. That way, we respect the past without distorting it, and we preserve a civic space that works for people of all beliefs.

It’s hard to imagine our nation surviving if it were forced to function as a Christian nation-state. That would be something entirely new and likely not something devout Christians or secular citizens would truly want. What has kept the U.S. strong is the balance struck by the founders: a theistic but pragmatic worldview that drew on Christian culture without enshrining it into law. To now push the country toward being something it never was does a disservice both to the founders’ intent and, I would argue, to Christianity itself.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?